USDA vs. FDA: Who Regulates What in U.S. Food Safety?

• In the United States, two main agencies—the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA)—are responsible for food inspection and safety. While both ensure that food products meet safety standards, their roles differ based on the type of food and the stage of production. Below is a breakdown of who regulates what.

USDA vs. FDA: Division of Responsibilities

The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) play complementary but distinct roles in regulating food safety. The USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS) primarily focuses on ensuring the safety, quality, and accurate labeling of meat, poultry, and certain egg products. In contrast, the FDA regulates the majority of other foods, including processed foods, beverages, seafood, and produce. This division helps streamline oversight, but it can also create some complexity around which agency is responsible for multi-ingredient products.

USDA Responsibilities

The USDA oversees foods derived from animals, such as:

• Meat products: Beef, pork, lamb, and other fresh or frozen meats.

• Poultry: Chicken, turkey, duck, and products containing significant amounts of these ingredients (like chicken sausages).

• Egg products: Liquid, dried, and frozen eggs, but not shell eggs sold in cartons (which the FDA regulates).

The USDA inspects slaughterhouses, processing plants, and facilities to ensure that these products meet health and safety standards from farm to market.

FDA Responsibilities

The FDA is responsible for regulating most other foods, such as:

• Processed foods: Packaged snacks, ready-to-eat meals, and canned goods.

• Dairy products: Milk, cheese, and yogurt.

• Produce: Fresh fruits and vegetables.

• Seafood: Fish, shellfish, and related products, though catfish falls under the USDA.

Why the Division Exists

The USDA’s focus on meat, poultry, and eggs stems from the origins of food regulation, where concerns over contamination in slaughterhouses led to stricter, continuous inspections. The FDA, on the other hand, oversees food products where risks tend to be lower, and inspections are less frequent but still systematic. While both agencies conduct inspections, the USDA has inspectors stationed on-site daily at facilities processing meat and poultry, while the FDA relies more on risk-based inspections at production facilities.

Challenges in the Overlap

This division sometimes creates confusion or overlap. For instance, a pepperoni pizza may require USDA inspection because it contains meat, while the pizza crust and sauce fall under FDA oversight. Both agencies work together in such cases to ensure food safety. Additionally, imported foods may require dual regulation, where meat shipments must meet USDA standards, and accompanying non-meat items are evaluated by the FDA.

Understanding these distinctions helps consumers and businesses navigate food regulations and clarifies which agency to contact for specific product issues.

Which Foods Fall Under FDA Jurisdiction?

The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) regulates the majority of food products in the United States that do not fall under the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA). While the USDA oversees meat, poultry, and some egg products, the FDA is responsible for ensuring the safety, labeling, and manufacturing practices for a broad range of foods. These include processed goods, beverages, seafood (with some exceptions), and produce. Below is a closer look at some specific food categories that fall under FDA oversight:

Processed and Packaged Foods

The FDA regulates foods that have been processed or packaged for retail sale. Examples include:

• Packaged snacks: Chips, crackers, granola bars, and popcorn.

• Baked goods: Bread, cookies, cakes, and pastries.

• Canned foods: Soups, vegetables, fruits, and sauces.

The agency ensures these products are manufactured under safe conditions, free from harmful contamination, and labeled with accurate ingredient lists and nutritional information.

Dairy Products

While USDA handles some aspects of milk grading, the FDA is responsible for regulating the safety and labeling of dairy products like:

• Milk and cream

• Cheese (including processed varieties such as cream cheese)

• Yogurt and butter

The FDA also sets standards for pasteurization to prevent harmful bacteria such as Listeria monocytogenes.

Seafood and Fish Products

Most seafood products, both fresh and processed, fall under the FDA’s jurisdiction. This includes:

• Salmon, tuna, shrimp, and lobster

• Canned seafood: Such as tuna, sardines, and crabmeat

• Frozen fish fillets

An exception to this is catfish, which is regulated by the USDA due to policy changes designed to ensure food safety through stricter inspections.

Produce and Fruits

The FDA is responsible for monitoring the safety of fresh fruits and vegetables. It plays a vital role in reducing contamination risks, particularly from pathogens like E. coli and Salmonella. Examples of produce under FDA jurisdiction include:

• Leafy greens: Lettuce, spinach, and kale

• Fruits: Apples, oranges, and berries

• Root vegetables: Potatoes, carrots, and onions

To minimize risks, the FDA enforces standards for Good Agricultural Practices (GAPs), which guide how farms grow, harvest, and package produce safely.

Beverages and Dietary Supplements

The FDA regulates both alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages, with oversight covering bottled water, soft drinks, fruit juices, and energy drinks. The agency also monitors dietary supplements, including vitamins, herbal products, and meal replacement shakes, to ensure they are properly labeled and free from harmful substances.

Cosmetic Borderline Products

Some food-related products, such as nutritional supplements and protein shakes, blur the lines between food and health products. These remain under the FDA’s purview to ensure they are safe for consumption and marketed without misleading claims.

In essence, the FDA ensures that foods consumed daily—from a bag of chips to fresh fruits—meet strict health and safety standards. This regulatory framework is designed to protect consumers from contamination, mislabeling, and harmful additives, while supporting the smooth flow of goods in the food supply chain.

USDA's Role in Meat and Poultry Inspection

The U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) is primarily responsible for ensuring that meat, poultry, and certain egg products are safe, wholesome, and properly labeled. The USDA’s Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS) conducts mandatory inspections at slaughterhouses and processing plants to detect contamination and verify that safety standards are followed throughout the production process. Unlike the FDA’s risk-based inspections, USDA inspections are continuous, meaning inspectors are present at facilities every day during production to guarantee compliance.

Inspection of Meat Products

The USDA inspects all domestically slaughtered animals, including cattle, pigs, lamb, and goats, before and after slaughter. These inspections aim to identify diseases or contaminants such as bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) in cattle or harmful bacteria like E. coli and Salmonella.

• Example: If a facility processes beef steaks or ground beef, USDA inspectors monitor everything from the animal’s arrival at the slaughterhouse to the packaging of the final product.

• USDA labeling: Products must carry the USDA inspection legend, a circular seal indicating the product has met safety standards.

USDA also regulates multi-ingredient products if they contain significant quantities of meat. For example, beef chili and spaghetti with meat sauce fall under USDA oversight because they contain more than 3% raw meat.

Inspection of Poultry Products

Similarly, the USDA ensures that poultry products (like chicken, turkey, and duck) meet health and safety standards. It inspects both whole birds and products like chicken nuggets, provided they contain at least 2% cooked poultry. USDA inspectors look for visible contamination, improper handling, and signs of disease in birds during slaughter and processing.

• Example: A facility that produces frozen chicken tenders requires daily USDA inspections to verify proper handling, storage, and processing procedures.

• Labeling: Like meat products, inspected poultry items must display the USDA’s inspection seal.

Egg Product Regulation

The USDA is responsible for certain egg products, specifically those that are processed into liquid, frozen, or dried forms. These include liquid eggs used in food service industries or packaged for consumers. However, shell eggs sold in cartons are regulated by the FDA, creating a shared responsibility.

• Example: A company selling liquid eggs for large-scale baking or breakfast buffets must comply with USDA regulations to ensure the product is free from Salmonella contamination.

Slaughterhouse and Processing Facility Oversight

USDA inspectors are required to be on-site daily at slaughterhouses and during production shifts in meat and poultry processing plants. Their responsibilities include:

• Checking sanitation procedures and ensuring the proper cleaning of equipment.

• Verifying that animals are handled humanely during slaughter.

• Monitoring temperature controls in storage and transportation to prevent spoilage.

These inspections are essential for protecting public health, as meat and poultry products carry higher risks of contamination compared to other foods. The USDA also ensures that packaging and labeling reflect the correct information, such as country of origin and nutritional details.

Shared Oversight and Borderline Cases

In some instances, food regulation in the U.S. falls under shared oversight between the USDA and FDA. This dual responsibility arises when a product contains a combination of meat, poultry, or eggs (regulated by the USDA) and other ingredients (regulated by the FDA). Determining which agency oversees such products depends on the quantity of meat or poultry involved, the nature of the food, and how the product is processed and sold. These borderline cases can create logistical challenges but ensure that foods meet safety standards regardless of their complexity.

Combination Foods: Who Regulates What?

When foods contain both meat and non-meat ingredients, the agency with the dominant regulatory interest takes the lead. If a product contains at least 3% raw meat or 2% cooked poultry, the USDA assumes regulatory control.

• Example: A pepperoni pizza sold in the frozen foods section is regulated by the USDA because it contains more than 3% meat (pepperoni). However, the same pizza's crust and tomato sauce must comply with FDA guidelines.

• Another Example: A vegetable soup with a small amount of chicken broth is regulated by the FDA, as the poultry content is minimal (below 2%).

This shared oversight ensures that both the meat and non-meat components meet safety and labeling standards appropriate to their risk levels.

Imported Foods: USDA and FDA Collaboration

Both agencies play critical roles in regulating imported foods to ensure that products entering the U.S. meet domestic safety standards.

• Example: Imported beef products must meet USDA inspection standards, while accompanying seasonings or sauces are evaluated by the FDA.

• Seafood imports: The FDA inspects most seafood, but catfish is regulated by the USDA due to more stringent rules introduced in recent years to protect public health.

The USDA and FDA work together at ports of entry, with inspectors from both agencies collaborating on products that involve overlapping responsibilities. This helps prevent contaminated foods from reaching consumers while facilitating trade.

Outbreak Response and Food Recalls

In cases of foodborne illness outbreaks or product recalls, both agencies may coordinate efforts, especially when contaminated foods involve both meat and non-meat ingredients.

• Example: If a pre-packaged salad containing chicken is found to carry Listeria, the USDA investigates the chicken component, while the FDA examines the vegetables and dressing. This collaborative approach ensures thorough investigation and mitigation.

• Recalls: Each agency publishes its own recalls but works closely to notify consumers when a product falls under shared jurisdiction.

Food Establishments with Multiple Product Types

Facilities that produce both USDA- and FDA-regulated products must adhere to the requirements of both agencies.

• Example: A food processing plant that manufactures both hot dogs (USDA) and potato chips (FDA) must maintain separate production areas or schedules to prevent cross-contamination and meet both sets of regulatory standards.

• Another Example: A facility producing breakfast sandwiches with eggs (regulated by USDA) must also comply with FDA rules if it makes accompanying smoothies or juices.

Challenges of Dual Oversight

Although shared regulation ensures comprehensive safety measures, it can create confusion for manufacturers and delays for importers. Businesses must navigate complex rules and may need to coordinate with both agencies when producing multi-ingredient foods. For example, an exporter shipping pasta with meat sauce must meet USDA rules for the sauce and FDA guidelines for the pasta component, increasing the compliance burden.

Food Safety Modernization Act and Cross-Agency Collaboration

The Food Safety Modernization Act (FSMA), enacted in 2011, marked a major shift in how the U.S. approaches food safety by emphasizing prevention over reaction to contamination. This law gave the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) expanded authority to implement preventive controls, conduct inspections, and enforce safety standards for the foods it regulates. However, the FSMA also highlights the need for collaboration between the FDA and USDA to ensure that food safety efforts are aligned, particularly when risks involve both agencies' jurisdictions.

The Role of FSMA in FDA-Handled Foods

The FSMA focuses heavily on ensuring the safety of produce, dairy, seafood, and processed foods—categories regulated by the FDA. It introduced requirements such as:

• Preventive controls: Manufacturers and producers must identify potential hazards and implement controls to prevent them.

• Produce safety standards: Farms growing fruits and vegetables (like spinach, lettuce, or strawberries) must follow Good Agricultural Practices (GAPs) to minimize contamination risks from sources like water, soil, and animal intrusion.

• Supplier verification: Companies must ensure their suppliers meet safety requirements, particularly for imported foods.

Example: An outbreak of E. coli linked to romaine lettuce prompted FSMA-mandated changes, requiring farms to improve water testing and sanitation procedures to prevent future contamination.

USDA’s Preventive Approach in Meat and Poultry

While the FSMA applies primarily to foods under FDA jurisdiction, the USDA has its own preventive framework for meat, poultry, and egg products. USDA-regulated facilities must implement Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points (HACCP) systems, which are similar to the preventive controls required by the FSMA. HACCP ensures that risks like bacterial contamination are identified and controlled throughout processing.

Example: A poultry plant under USDA inspection must monitor critical points such as temperature control during processing to prevent the growth of Salmonella.

The alignment between FSMA's preventive controls and USDA’s HACCP system ensures a consistent safety approach across all food categories, even though the agencies oversee different products.

Cross-Agency Collaboration During Outbreaks

Foodborne illness outbreaks often require the FDA and USDA to work together, especially when the contaminated product falls under dual jurisdiction. Both agencies share data, coordinate investigations, and issue recalls to minimize public health risks.

• Example: If a contamination event involves a chicken Caesar salad, the USDA would investigate the chicken, while the FDA would examine the lettuce and dressing. This collaborative effort ensures every component of the product is evaluated.

The two agencies also partner with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) to trace outbreaks and inform the public about food safety risks. These partnerships allow the agencies to act quickly in crisis situations.

Joint Efforts in Import Safety

The FSMA also enhances the FDA’s ability to regulate imported foods, with the USDA playing a key role in the inspection of meat imports.

Example: Imported beef must meet USDA standards, while the FDA monitors any accompanying side dishes or sauces that come with it. Both agencies coordinate to ensure that foods produced abroad meet U.S. safety requirements.

Additionally, the FDA and USDA work together at ports of entry, where inspectors ensure that imported foods are free from contamination and accurately labeled.

Technology and Information Sharing

The FSMA encourages the use of technology to streamline inspections and improve coordination between agencies. Shared databases allow the USDA and FDA to track inspection results, monitor recalls, and exchange information in real-time. This collaboration enables both agencies to stay informed about safety risks across the food supply chain.

Example: If a batch of contaminated beef triggers a recall, the FDA uses the USDA’s inspection data to identify related risks in products containing that beef (e.g., frozen beef burritos).

The FSMA represents a significant step toward a preventive, risk-based food safety system, with the USDA and FDA working together to ensure comprehensive protection across all food categories. By aligning preventive controls with existing HACCP frameworks, sharing data, and coordinating efforts during outbreaks and recalls, the two agencies effectively safeguard the U.S. food supply. This cross-agency collaboration not only strengthens domestic food safety but also ensures that imported products meet the same rigorous standards.

Become PCQI certified - 100% online

If you are interested in becoming a PCQI certified, or simply aiming to comply with FSMA, explore our 100% online PCQI training. EnsureIQ offers fully online, web-based food safety training with certifications. Browse our range of available courses, including HACCP certification and allergen awareness training in both English and Spanish.